waste it again

Arcade Fire - The Suburbs (continued) {Christian TV Remix}
As much as I like the new Arcade Fire album - and I really like it a lot - every time I listen to it, it's with a measure of resignation. This is the album where I finally accept that they are going to be a great band, but not an astonishing band, not the band they once promised to be, or seemed to. It's a typical feeling, I know, and I can't expect any band to get come as close to perfection twice as they did with Funeral.
The Suburbs is a fine album, but of all their records, it means the least to me. Not just because I grew up in a small Irish town instead of a fading American suburb, but because I made the mistake of hoping for a bit more. The band has to escape the place they occupy in my musical scrapbook and start something new - and indeed, one of the finest songs on the album is the least typical thing they've ever done: 'Sprawl II (Mountains Beyond Mountains)' is them forgetting what worked before and making everything anew, and it's stunning, and just enough to make me think that despite my overarching expectations, and despite the impossibly high standards of their debut, the band might well do it again, in a different life, freed of old expectations. This time, they've made the best record they could, and it's churlish to expect more than that.




